Dvd
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
This F. Scott Fitzgerald novella adaptation is the story of Benjamin Button (Brad Pitt), born a feeble old man who ages backwards, eventually dying as a baby. Naturally enough, this leads to issues - romance and maturity are OK in the middle years when his physical and mental age meet, but bigger problems arise at either end of the age spectrum. Fitzgerald remarked, "this story was inspired by a remark of Mark Twain’s to the effect that it was a pity that the best part of life came at the beginning and the worst part at the end".
Directed by David Fincher (who reached a new high with last year's Zodiac), adapted for the screen by Eric Roth (The Insider, Forrest Gump).
Starring Brad Pitt, Cate Blanchett, Tilda Swinton, Elle Fanning, Julia Ormond
Directed by David Fincher ('Zodiac', 'Panic Room', 'Fight Club', 'Se7en')
Written by Eric Roth (based on the short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald)
Festivals & Awards Best Art Direction, Make Up and Visual Effects - Academy Awards 2009.
Drama, Adaptation | 2hr 39mins | Rated (M) | contains offensive language & sexual references | Origin: USA
Flicks review
-
The problem with visionary directors like David Fincher is that sometimes, perhaps, we expect a little too much. This fantastical tale, the reunion of the Seven/Fight Club director with Tyler Durden himself, Brad Pitt, has been looking like a potential masterpiece for months. As it turns out it’s not perfect, it’s just very, very good. And that’s ever so slightly disappointing.
Benjamin Button has so much going for it though. There’s beautiful earthen-hued cinematography throughout. There’s a convincing, controlled performance from Pitt, natural enough to stop you obsessing over the amazing ageing effects once the initial novelty has worn off. There’s a story which, while it has little to do with its Fitzgerald source material (except for the basic premise), does throw in a little bit of excitement for all tastes, with moments of self-discovery, high adventure, humour and romance.
But on the downside, the story unfolds in such an unhurried, best-part-of-three-hours way that it sometimes drags, with the love story between Button and Cate Blanchett’s Daisy proving both the heart of the film, and its least interesting element – the early womanizing and wartime scenes are much more fun. Add in a distracting, unnecessary modern day Hurricane Katrina side-theme and there are undoubtedly a few blemishes here.
So what sounded like it could be one of Fincher’s strangest films, in fact comes out as one of his most accessible – a less madcap, more grandiose Big Fish. It may have a crinkly bub gradually morphing into a teenager in it, but essentially it’s a star-crossed love story with philosophical accoutrements. Go into this expecting a feast of offbeat originality, or thrills and spills throughout and you’ll feel a bit let down. But expect elegance, tenderness and stunning visuals and you’ll be repaid warmly.
By Ashley Bird, Flicks.co.nz
The Peoples voice
-
5
I think The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button is an amazing and powerful movie! However it was a very sad movie, but it was one of the best movies i have ever seen. I give the movie infinity stars! I LOVE YOU BRAD PITT!!!!!
By Nadia
-
...MeAn BUTTON MeAn...
5
I think it was really awesome and interesting. It had a great story line and I think the actors were spot on. I can at least say it was way BETTER!!! than twilight. Big props to the director, how many of us can say we actually got to see a different unfamiliar movie like this. Which HEY Brad Pitt was lead... "TooDleS"
By HeHe
-
its good movie
4
but is very personal, the only way you will understand this is watching it.
It may send you on journey of reflections about you own life, or it might just bore you do death if you´re not in the mood...By Julioc
-
Yawn....
OH MY SWEET JESEUS!!!!! I feel for the first time in my life that I have truly wasted my time. I was very aware that I was in a dark room with a hundred strangers, well I suppose better that than having to listen to this tripe. Worst piece of crap I’ve seen since my last bad bout of food poisoning.
Basically, a troll gets younger as each year goes by and believe me, that takes just as long as it sounds. Go see it if you want to see and old man pervert a small child, get on a small boat, live in a small cold country while steadily getting less and less wrinkled. I could see the same thing after getting out of long bath.
The only light relief was an old man who was continuously struck by lightning, this however was also mercilessly stabbed to death by the time it was shown for the 3rd of 7 times. This "film" was void of any interest, emotion, acting ability, engagement and every other aspect that could make any motion picture watchable.
To compare it to other movies would be wrong. I prefer to compare it to having my fingernails slowly pulled out while having a fat man sit on my face, at least that’s what Brad Pitt must have been threatened with to accept this role which he carried off without a hint of enthusiasm or display that he had ever acted before. Don’t go to see this movie, as Benjamin gets younger and younger, you must endure this lifeless tale while you only get older and older.By Thomas
-
COMPLETE AND UTTER BOLLOCKS - AVOID!
OMG this film is total, complete and utter bollocks. People were walking out! Maybe would've been OK if it were 1.5 hours shorter. Cate Blanchetts voice as an old lady is one of the most annoying sounds you will ever hear in your life. The movie just goes on and on. By the midway point you actually start looking forward to them dying. By the end you're cheering!
By Popsicle
-
disappointing to say the least
3
I went in excited to watch this movie but halfway through it got quite boring and to be honest very unbelieveable..I like to go in and feel engrossed in the movie especially when you are paying so much for a movie and popcorn...this movie was not one of them i came out feeling like i had wasted my money and may as well of waited until it came out on video and when i say video i mean $3 weekly :(
By Genevieve
-
Overly long
3
Oh dear, numb bum syndrome set in after two hours and it was difficult to concentrate despite the beatifully crafted sets and detailed cinematography or the acting skills of the principle actors -Tilda Swinton was the standout for me. This story could have had more light relief and at least half an hour shaved off which would have given it some pace.However still an original idea for Hollywood and for that top marks.
By Jo
-
Entertaining enough
3
Though if you think about it, rather ridiculous.
Clearly, very popular. Great acting, great effects.By brian
-
Rich, colourful, mind boggling!
5
See this film! Cate Blanchett is just incredible! Brad Pitt's performance exceede all his other work, and this film makes you think about it for ages afterward. It is a tad slow in places, but it's fabulous all the same!
By Jack
-
Well, it seemed like a lifetime.....
1
While the storyline had promise, in my opinion this the film failed to deliver. It was long-winded, uninspiring and when the credits finally appeared a weight was lifted off my shoulders.
By Grant
-
Edward Scissorhands and Forest Gump, but neither...
2
Check Ben's father, Vincent Price look a like? Yes we've seen this film, and short story before - Burton and Zemeckis did it better, so Fincher didn't really try. Neither did Brad Pitt, he'd already played the role perfectly well in "Meet Joe Black", and well, Cate Blanchett played the whole thing angry she wasn't Claire Forlani, Robin Wright, or Winona Ryder - Ryder? Johnny Depp's girlfriend in "Scissorhands" and Depp's actual old Girlfriend, Depp? Pitt before Pitt. Robin Wright? Princess, in "The Princess Bride", Forest Gump's HIV Girlfriend "Jenny", you remember?! Watch Edward, Forest, even the Angel of Death, but Ben? Not if I have to watch that baby close its eyes, and hear that dialogue again...Ben dies in Daisy's arms a newborn baby, his whole life flashing before his eyes...and his daughter to Daisy, thinks he's a prick...run the end credits and let me go home already, far out, its 11.10pm!
By Faafetai
-
Emotionally gripping
5
Beautiful film that drew me into the love story between to people. The aging of Brad Pitt was almost a gimmick, he really started to look believable when the makeup came off.
Great story.By Doug
-
4
Well I have to say the reviews of this film are more than a little harsh. Perhaps too many young Brad fans, or "older" people with limited imaginations went to see it. I wanted to give this film a 4 and three quarters but the star rating wouldn't let me.
I went into this film with high hopes and was not disappointed; Mr Pitt continues his run of picking nothing but the best scripts to work with.
Sure, there are some nifty special effects, and the story is completely ludicrous but once you look past that and concentrate on the message behind the story, its a fantastic movie, captivating, beautifully directed, and elegant.
And the message? Youth is wasted on the young. Anybody under the age of 30 or so probably would miss that, having not lived enough life to realise how good life really was when they were younger, but I am sure it's not a message lost on the rest of us.
There's no happy ending here, this is not a movie where love overcomes all, but one with a far harsher reality - no matter how much you love someone, there are some situations that can not be conquered.
I didn't appreciate the Hurricane Katrina / dying mother's last words sub-plot, nor the little hummingbird that keeps popping up - far too 5th form exam "Can you pick the themes in this movie" for me, but those are minor elements in the film, and in no way overshadow the charm of this movie.
See it and decide for yourself. Just don't get hung up on the special effects or the premise - reverse ageing is not what the movie is about.
By N.Y
-
Giant baby
4
One problem with this movie is that Benjamin is born as a tiny little old man - as opposed to completing his life as a full sized old man..
Therefore, he should have come to the end of his life as a gigantic baby. I was very disappointed that this was not to be.By Sam
-
An emotional epic
5
This film is extremely well doneand it hit me emotionally on many levels. I didn't even mind the fact it was 2 hrs 40 minslong as it was that good. Brad Pitt plays his role extraordinarily well alongside a standout performance from Cate Blanchett. Highly recommended to anyone, especially those who wish to delve deeper into the real meaning of ageing itself.
By Shaun
-
rubbish
1
Slow boring and just a bit rubbish . shame on you Cate!
By kate k
-
Forrest Gump-ish
4
This was really enjoyable. It reminded me of Forrest Gump in many ways, but mainly because of the film's reflective nature and analysis of a person's entire lifetime.
Great performances. Romantic and sad.
A shame, as Flicks as some users mention, it was a bit 'safe'... could've had more balls. But that's a pretty minor criticism for a film that is very enjoyable - makes one reflect.By S.L.
-
Interesting
3
i thought that the film was a bit boring ! but it wasnt what i expected ! it was different ! and funny . with the guy that always said "have i told you about the time i was struck by lighting ?' that was funny !
i know that the movie was not for my target audience but i still enjoyed it !
plus when brad pitt went younger into his teens he looked like he just had botox ! =D LBMO !By Lilah
-
Great Premise - boring film
1
Okay I had been warned from reading the reviews that this film was slow moving but oh my it was so slow and it never got started. I wish I had known that the only exploration of this concept made in this film was a love story between Pitt and Blanchett. There was so much more that they could have done, the love story could still be there, but there could have been so much more.
Very disappointing film and at 2 hrs 40 minutes it is a long time to be bored. I would have walked out but I kept waiting for something to happen.
Girls will probably enjoy it - but word of advise go with another girlfriend leave your man at home. He will most likely hate it (unless he is a total romantic and likes long drawn out romance movies)By Carryn
-
Interesting concept
4
Yes, it's quite slow moving. And the aging effects are quite gimmicky to start off with. But once the love story bit gets underway, and Brad Pitt begins to look a bit like the Pitt we know, the movie gets into its stride. Quite melancholic and subdued. Really enjoyed it. Perhaps could have taken a few more risks.
By Andy
-
A brilliant idea for a film
4
i cant wait for this film to be released. I have always wondered what would happen if my life started at the end, the issues would be endless the benefits too numerous to mention and you would begin with all the experience in the world and slowly start making mistakes that you wouldn't never have done if you had the experience..WOW my brain is aching even now just trying to fathom it all out....To sum up....I cannot wait, to find out how the movie world deal with this and the cast look fantastic. There are so many different ways this idea could go and though it may not be an oscar winning film hopefully i am wrong there, but the thought provoking story will have people talking about it for years to come
By Steve daulby
Press Reviews
-
FilmThreat.com [USA]
Benjamin Button is pretty much just "Gump" with better cinematography.
Click to read the full review -
Hollywood Reporter
Superbly made and winningly acted by Brad Pitt in his most impressive outing to date.
Click to read the full review -
Los Angeles Times
As enervating as it is long -- and at 2 hours and 47 minutes it is quite long -- this version of the F. Scott Fitzgerald fantasy short story is a baffling project, an endurance test of a movie that feels like it was made on a dare.
Click to read the full review -
NZ Herald [Francesca Rudkin]
5 5 out of 5 stars
The outcome may be inevitable from the start, but the emotional punch it delivers captures you by surprise, confirming that this eclectic and overly long journey was worth the watch.
Click to read the full review -
Premiere [USA]
Naturally, Pitt and Blanchett are outstanding. Fincher's meticulous attention to detail is unerring, down to the light fixtures.
Click to read the full review -
Stuff.co.nz
Underpinning it all is a meditation on the double-edged nature of time and the spiralling twists a life takes en route to its end. Time is brutal, the film is saying. Fitzgerald was right about that. Yet there can be moments that defeat time by enduring as long as they remain in someone's memory.
Click to read the full review -
The Press [Margaret Agnew]
4 4 out of 5 stars
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is perfect escapism for these uncertain times, to remind us to make the most of the life we're given. It's also proof that mainstream Hollywood can still break out in imaginative, unexpected, oddly satisfying ways.
Click to read the full review -
TV3 [Kate Rodger]
A curious, compelling little love story, and one I urge you not to miss.
Click to read the full review -
Urban Cinefile [Australia]
Somewhat bloated and relying on its novelty value, the screenplay lumbers when it should be sprightly, and its rare moments of humour are limited to a running gag about an old man being struck by lightning - seven times. My disappointment with the film is made the more severe by the fact that it strikes so many emotional truths about humanity . . . and is so well made.
Click to read the full review -
Variety [USA]
This odd, epic tale of a man who ages backwards is presented in an impeccable classical manner, every detail tended to with fastidious devotion.
Click to read the full review
Search For a DVD
I beg your pardon?
- Flicks.co.nz is serving the great nation of NZ with all things cinematic. Question about a movie or cinema? Thoughts on the site? Quips, gripes, advice for our own personal self-development?
- Get in touch with us by email at ED@ FLICKS.CO.NZ,on TWITTER oron FACEBOOK.













