I Know What You Did Last Summer (2025)

"Wasn't worth waiting for."

"The horrors of the nostalgia well running dry."

"An unextreme slasher movie."

"Not scary enough to thrill, funny enough to charm, or clever enough to convince."

"Legacy sequel not worth screaming about."

"Pretty vapid stuff until the OGs arrive."

"Lean, mean serial killer flick."

"Barely earns the right to a theatrical release."

"It’s possible that this will live on mostly as a pop culture curio."

"History may have given the first film a reputation as dumb fun, but this one’s just dumb."

"Higher body count and a new cast of genuinely likable characters."

"Clever moments and a sensational performance from Madelyn Cline."

"Kept me interested, even if it also made me braindead."